Nomadland: American Honey For Boomers

When you go searching for the soul of America, what do you find? This is the driving question at the heart of many seminal pieces of art. Artists across time have been chasing it and the highly buzzed about film “Nomadland” is no exception. From rising (or should I say current) superstar director Chloe Zhao - the film tells the story of 60 year old Fern (Frances McDormand) who after losing her husband and her whole town (literally, her zip code is removed from the post office record) sets out in a van to find herself and America. And so, the aforementioned search begins. 

nomadland-013_NML_SG_00630_R_V2_rgb-1.jpg

Let’s get one thing out of the way first - this movie is beautiful to look at. In fact it's pretty much the first art house movie I can think of that is getting an IMAX release. Joshua James Richards, the film’s cinematographer, uses almost all natural light to capture everything from the craggy beauty of Badlands national park to the all consuming sprawl of an Amazon warehouse (Amazon is one of the many jobs that Fern has throughout the film). Richards calls his style “heightened, super cinematic naturalism,” and that really makes sense as the film spends equal tender time on people’s faces as it does on stunning landscapes. But now that we’ve established that the film looks amazing and will make you want to visit some national parks - let’s talk about the rest of the movie, specifically the huge element that’s missing in it that really holds it back: danger.

For a movie that is keen on referencing the cinematic language of westerns and features a stubborn and resourceful main character - there is never any real element of danger. You never are really concerned for Fern. She’s out here ripping through this new-american frontier, but the most intense thing that happens to her is when a person knocks on her van and tells her to move it. There is also some car trouble. The American landscape has always been unforgiving and this film seems to pull back a little bit on it. I’m not expecting some bear attack like “The Revenant” but just something that raises the stakes more for Fern. 

Sasha Lane in American Honey

Sasha Lane in American Honey

While watching this film I kept thinking about a movie about American nomads, but one with a lot more edge and danger - 2016’s “American Honey,” which if you haven’t seen is an absolute masterpiece. Like “Nomadland,” “American Honey” tells the story of a female protagonist (albeit much younger) who travels the American landscape searching for the soul of America. The lead actress in the film, Sasha Lane, was cast by the director Andrea Arnold while partying on a beach in Florida. Lane plays a character named Star, the role is her acting debut. Her being a completely new fresh face gives the film a powerful aura - it feels like you’re watching life unfold because you’ve never seen her before. In “Nomadland,” some of the themes are dulled because Frances McDormand is an Oscar winning actress. I’m not watching Fern. I'm watching a two time Oscar winner. This is kind of ironic because Zhao’s previous film “The Rider” featured a cast of complete unknowns and is remarkable. Also, an important note is that “The Rider” is one of the greatest movies ever made.

Maybe I’m missing the point. I mean, I can write multiple essays on my love for “American Honey,” but ultimately that movie is what it means to be young in America. “Nomadland” is a movie about what it means to be old in America. Fern is 60 in the film (which isn’t that old) her desires in the film are focused on a horizon that is much closer than one portrayed in “American Honey.” There’s a lot of talk about death with dignity. And for that reason I really see “Nomadland” as kind of a boomer tone poem about finding yourself when you don’t recognize the world around you anymore. Perhaps I’ll revisit the film when I’m 60 and it will blow my mind to pieces - but until then I’ll stick with “American Honey” and it’s danger and rawness. Ha - “danger and rawness” - sounds like American in 2021.